Frosty Moose

Discover Frosty Moose Ice Cream Shop at 35 W Geneva St, Williams Bay, WI. Enjoy a variety of delicious flavors, cones, gluten-free options, and a cozy patio. Perfect for families and ice cream lovers!

Welcome to Frosty Moose

Experience the finest dining

Frosty Moose
Frosty Moose
Frosty Moose
Frosty Moose

Frosty Moose sits at the heart of Williams Bay, welcoming locals and visitors alike. This charming ice cream shop, located at 35 W Geneva St, is not just a treat spot but a cozy gathering place. With a menu full of delightful sandwiches and decadent ice creams, there’s something for everyone. The staff greets you with a smile, ready to serve up classic flavors and innovative combinations. Families love grabbing a scoop after a day of exploring the nearby Geneva Lake. The inviting patio allows guests to enjoy their treats in the fresh air, making each visit a breezy, enjoyable experience. Whether you come for the ice cream or the sandwiches, Frosty Moose creates memories to savor all season long.

Frosty Moose boasts a range of enticing features that set it apart. The shop offers a seasonal variety of ice cream flavors, with unique options like Cherry Swirl alongside classic favorites. Customers rave about the Crunch Cone, adding a satisfying crunch to every creamy bite. For those seeking something more substantial, the menu includes sandwiches that pack a punch.

Try the Roast Beef Sandwich for a hearty meal or the refreshing Egg Salad Sandwich, both crafted to satisfy your appetite. The pet-friendly patio feels like a hidden gem in town, perfect for enjoying a summer evening or a cozy afternoon. Plus, gluten-free options ensure that everyone can indulge in a sweet treat. Frosty Moose creates a family-friendly atmosphere where food lovers gather to relax and enjoy.

Location & Contact

The Setting

Address

35 W Geneva St, Williams Bay, WI 53191, United States

Phone

+1 262-245-2445

Social Media

About

The Journey Behind the Flavor

Frosty Moose
Frosty Moose
Frosty Moose
Frosty Moose

Frosty Moose was established to bring joy and delicious flavors to Williams Bay. The shop pays homage to classic Americana, combining a nostalgic ice cream parlor feel with modern vibes. Inside, you’ll find cheerful decor and a welcoming atmosphere that draws in families and friends. The focus here is on community—whether it’s a local gathering or a summer event, Frosty Moose hosts occasions that celebrate the spirit of togetherness.

The menu, though not extensive, is curated with care, offering seven delicious items that locals adore. From delightful ice cream sundaes like the Prairie Dirt Sundae to sumptuous sandwiches, every dish reflects a dedication to quality ingredients. This commitment to flavor shines through in every scoop, as well as in the choice of local produce whenever possible. Seasonal offerings keep the menu fresh and engaging, giving regulars something to look forward to each visit.

Those who dine at Frosty Moose often find themselves in deep conversations over a scoop or two, metaphorically navigating the flavors of Williams Bay life. The balance of sweet treats and hearty sandwiches, made fresh daily, makes Frosty Moose a must-visit destination.

Frosty Moose

Frosty Moose features a welcoming exterior that invites you in. The charming facade, with its playful signage and bright colors, immediately evokes a sense of nostalgia. The patio is a communal hub, filled with laughter and the scent of fresh ice cream wafting through the air. Sunlight dapples through nearby trees, creating a cozy vibe that tugs at the heartstrings.

Residents often spot their neighbors here, sharing stories over cold treats. The atmospheric evenings sparkle with shared joy and delight, making it a prized part of the Williams Bay landscape.

Work Hours

Reservations & Service Hours

  • SundayOpen
  • MondayOpen
  • TuesdayOpen
  • WednesdayOpen
  • ThursdayOpen
  • FridayOpen
  • SaturdayOpen

Guestbook & Reviews

Customer Reviews

Great sandwiches, wraps & service. We've loved everything so far, with the Ceasar Chicken Wrap and the Corned Beef being outstanding. HUGE single scoop ice cream - great flavors.

R
Ryan Y.

Great spot for sandwiches and ice cream. Tons of flavors to choose from with a great Oreo one. Nice patio off to the side.

A
Amanda D.

Stopped to check out on Sandwichs. As a vegetarian, it is hard to find good options. Got an egg salad sandwich, and it comes with cheese and veggies. Grabbed an ice cream butter pecan on a chocolate cone as well. Perfect for the hot day. Took my sandwich to go so I could enjoy it at the pool. I'm definitely coming back as it's close by my home.

M
Mylla P.

There was plenty of meat in my roast beef sandwich and you get your choice of condiments, very fresh. All in all, a flavorful combo. I also got a huge scoop of praline pecan. I apologize, I enjoyed about half of the food before I took a picture. It was that good. Enjoy it while it lasts, though... I was told they close for the season around Halloween.

E
Esther

Due to weather we had to change our group's evening plans. Two of us stopped by the Frosty Moose (without warning) to buy ice cream for our very large group. The owners and staff were incredibly accommodating, providing us advice about flavors for kids and adults, but also providing us with timely service. They went above and beyond what I expected and everyone loved the ice cream. They seem like a golden business.

B
Byron S.

This is probably my favorite ice cream shop in the area. I swear I get withdrawals when they're closed in the off season. Their prairie dirt sundae (kind of like a dirt cup with ice cream instead of pudding) is what childhood dreams are made of. It's got a base of Oreo ice cream, Oreo dirt, gummy worms, whipped cream, and some sort of marshmallow topping that takes it to the next level. Seriously, get it, it's that good. I've also had the spicy chicken wrap here which was great. Always great service.

G
Grant P.